Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier

Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
Autobeaming now depends on context properties that can be
\set by the user.   When the time signature is changed, default
autobeam settings for the time signature are read and the context
properties are changed to set the autobeaming properties.

This change eliminates \overrideBeamSettings and \revertBeamSettings.

New functions have been defined to set time signature default
properties:
\overrideTimeSignatureSettings
and
\revertTimeSignatureSettings
in order to give autobeam settings persistence through time signature
changes.

A Scheme function make-setting has been defined to make it
easier to create a time signature setting.

[Carl, 2010-06-13 01:47:54]

I have *finally* completed the autobeaming patch.

The patch eliminates beamSettings as a major alist containing settings for
various time signatures.

Instead, autobeaming is controlled by some simple context properties:

beamSettings, beatLength, and measureGrouping.

In order to give a persistent setting for autobeaming, there is also a context
property timeSignatureSettings that stores default values of measureGrouping,
beatLength, and beamSettings for a given time signature.

The defaults can be overridden and reverted with overrideTimeSignatureSettings
and revertTimeSignatureSettings.

To facilitate doing the override, there is a scheme function make-setting that
constructs the appropriate timeSignatureSetting from a given beatLength,
measureGrouping, and beamSettings.

This patch contains lots of snippets because I needed to run makelsr in order to
get the snippets out of Documentation/snippets/new/ in order to test the
documentation build.

Thanks,

Carl

[t.daniels_treda.co.uk, 2010-06-13 07:32:29]

Carl

At first glance this looks like a major improvement!

I'm tied up today, but I'll give it a whirl within a
day or two.

Trevor

----- Original Message ----- 
From: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
To: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
Cc: <reply@codereview.appspotmail.com>; <lilypond-devel@gnu.org>
Sent: Sunday, June 13, 2010 2:47 AM
Subject: Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier 
(issue1667041)


> Reviewers: ,
>
> Message:
> I have *finally* completed the autobeaming patch.
>
> The patch eliminates beamSettings as a major alist containing 
> settings
> for various time signatures.
>
> Instead, autobeaming is controlled by some simple context 
> properties:
>
> beamSettings, beatLength, and measureGrouping.
>
> In order to give a persistent setting for autobeaming, there is 
> also a
> context property timeSignatureSettings that stores default values 
> of
> measureGrouping, beatLength, and beamSettings for a given time
> signature.
>
> The defaults can be overridden and reverted with
> overrideTimeSignatureSettings and revertTimeSignatureSettings.
>
> To facilitate doing the override, there is a scheme function
> make-setting that constructs the appropriate timeSignatureSetting 
> from a
> given beatLength, measureGrouping, and beamSettings.
>
> This patch contains lots of snippets because I needed to run 
> makelsr in
> order to get the snippets out of Documentation/snippets/new/ in 
> order to
> test the documentation build.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Carl
>
>
> Description:
> Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
> Autobeaming now depends on context properties that can be
> \set by the user.   When the time signature is changed, default
> autobeam settings for the time signature are read and the context
> properties are changed to set the autobeaming properties.
>
> This change eliminates \overrideBeamSettings and 
> \revertBeamSettings.
>
> New functions have been defined to set time signature default
> properties:
> \overrideTimeSignatureSettings
> and
> \revertTimeSignatureSettings
> in order to give autobeam settings persistence through time 
> signature
> changes.
>
> A Scheme function make-setting has been defined to make it
> easier to create a time signature setting.
>
> Please review this at http://codereview.appspot.com/1667041/show
>
> Affected files:
>   M Documentation/de/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/es/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/fr/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/snippets/accordion-discant-symbols.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-a-figured-bass-above-or-below-the-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-ambitus-per-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-bar-lines-to-chordnames-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-drum-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-fingerings-to-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-the-current-date-to-a-score.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-volta-brackets-to-additional-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/additional-voices-to-avoid-collisions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adjusting-lyrics-vertical-spacing.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adjusting-the-shape-of-falls-and-doits.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/aligning-bar-numbers.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/aligning-marks-with-various-notation-objects.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/allowing-fingerings-to-be-printed-inside-the-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ambitus-with-multiple-voices.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-fonts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-gregorian-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-mensural-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/applying-note-head-styles-depending-on-the-step-of-the-scale.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/arabic-improvisation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beams-across-line-breaks.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing--flageolet-mark-size.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-beam-knee-gap.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-chord-separator.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-form-of-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-partcombine-texts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-text-and-spanner-styles-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-breath-mark-symbol.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-positions-of-figured-bass-alterations.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tempo-without-a-metronome-mark.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tuplet-number.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-exceptions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-major7.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chordchanges-for-fretboards.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chords-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/clip-systems.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/combining-two-parts-on-the-same-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/contemporary-glissando.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-spanner-visibility-after-a-line-break.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-placement-of-chord-fingerings.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-vertical-ordering-of-scripts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/creating-a-delayed-turn.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-arpeggios-across-notes-in-different-voices.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-a-piano-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-other-contexts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-metronome-marks-in-markup-mode.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-fretboard-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-markup-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/default-direction-of-stems-on-the-center-line-of-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/defining-predefined-fretboards-for-other-instruments.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/display-bracket-with-only-one-staff-in-a-system.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-complex-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-grob-ancestry.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/dodecaphonic-style-accidentals-for-each-note-including-naturals.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-custom-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/editorial-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/engraving-ties-manually.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/entering-several-tuplets-using-only-one--times-command.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/expressive-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/faking-a-hammer-in-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/figured-bass-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/fingerings,-string-indications,-and-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flamenco-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flat-flags-and-beam-nibs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/forcing-horizontal-shift-of-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/fretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/grid-lines--changing-their-appearance.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/grouping-beats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-slides.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-strum-rhythms.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/hiding-the-extender-line-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/incipit.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/indicating-cross-staff-chords-with-arpeggio-bracket.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/inserting-a-caesura.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/isolated-percent-repeats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/jazz-combo-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/keyboard-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/letter-tablature-formatting.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/makam-example.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-slurs-with-complex-dash-structure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-some-staff-lines-thicker-than-the-others.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/mensurstriche-layout-bar-lines-between-the-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/modern-tab-text-clef.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/modifying-default-values-for-articulation-shorthand-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/multi-measure-rest-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/nesting-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/new/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/new/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/fretted-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-default-tuplet-numbers.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-traditional-key-signatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/numbers-as-easy-note-heads.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/orchestra,-choir-and-piano-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ottava-text.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-count-visibility.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-counter.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/permitting-line-breaks-within-beamed-tuplets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-melody-and-lyrics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/pitches-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/placement-of-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/polyphony-in-tablature.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-grace-notes-with-floating-space.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/positioning-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-text-markups-inside-slurs.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-extra-naturals-from-being-automatically-added.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-natural-signs-from-being-printed-when-the-key-signature-changes.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-a-repeat-sign-at-the-beginning-of-a-piece.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-at-regular-intervals.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-inside-boxes-or-circles.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-hairpins-using-al-niente-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/printing-marks-on-every-staff.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/printing-metronome-and-rehearsal-marks-below-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-the-bar-number-for-the-first-measure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice-with-transposition.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/redefining-grace-note-global-defaults.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-bar-numbers-from-a-score.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-the-first-empty-line.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/repeats-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rest-styles.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rhythms-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/scheme-engraver-ambitus.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/screech-boink.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-hairpin-behavior-at-bar-lines.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-the-minimum-length-of-hairpins.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/shortening-volta-brackets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/showing-chords-at-changes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simple-lead-sheet.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simultaneous-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes,-lyrics,-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-only-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/snap-pizzicato-bartok-pizzicato.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/staff-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stand-alone-two-column-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stem-and-beam-behavior-in-tablature.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-with-separate-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/sub-dividing-beams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/text-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/transposing-pitches-with-minimum-accidentals-smart-transpose.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-clef-properties.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-grace-layout-within-music.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/unfretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/use-square-bracket-at-the-start-of-a-staff-group.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-double-slurs-for-legato-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-grace-note-slashes-with-normal-heads.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-ly-grob-object-to-access-grobs-with--tweak.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-the-whiteout-property.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-ties-with-arpeggios.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligned-dynamics-and-textscripts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligning-ossias-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-automatic-piano-reduction.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-lyrics-aligned-below-and-above-the-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-verse-and-refrain.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/volta-below-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/wind-headword.ly
>   M input/regression/les-nereides.ly
>   M lily/auto-beam-engraver.cc
>   M lily/beam-setting-scheme.cc
>   M lily/beaming-pattern.cc
>   M lily/include/beam-settings.hh
>   M lily/measure-grouping-engraver.cc
>   M ly/bagpipe.ly
>   M ly/engraver-init.ly
>   M ly/music-functions-init.ly
>   M python/convertrules.py
>   M scm/auto-beam.scm
>   M scm/define-context-properties.scm
>   M scm/lily-library.scm
>   M scm/lily.scm
>   M scm/music-functions.scm
>   A scm/time-signature-settings.scm
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-devel mailing list
> lilypond-devel@gnu.org
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
>
> 

[t.daniels_treda.co.uk, 2010-06-13 07:32:29]

Carl

At first glance this looks like a major improvement!

I'm tied up today, but I'll give it a whirl within a
day or two.

Trevor

----- Original Message ----- 
From: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
To: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
Cc: <reply@codereview.appspotmail.com>; <lilypond-devel@gnu.org>
Sent: Sunday, June 13, 2010 2:47 AM
Subject: Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier 
(issue1667041)


> Reviewers: ,
>
> Message:
> I have *finally* completed the autobeaming patch.
>
> The patch eliminates beamSettings as a major alist containing 
> settings
> for various time signatures.
>
> Instead, autobeaming is controlled by some simple context 
> properties:
>
> beamSettings, beatLength, and measureGrouping.
>
> In order to give a persistent setting for autobeaming, there is 
> also a
> context property timeSignatureSettings that stores default values 
> of
> measureGrouping, beatLength, and beamSettings for a given time
> signature.
>
> The defaults can be overridden and reverted with
> overrideTimeSignatureSettings and revertTimeSignatureSettings.
>
> To facilitate doing the override, there is a scheme function
> make-setting that constructs the appropriate timeSignatureSetting 
> from a
> given beatLength, measureGrouping, and beamSettings.
>
> This patch contains lots of snippets because I needed to run 
> makelsr in
> order to get the snippets out of Documentation/snippets/new/ in 
> order to
> test the documentation build.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Carl
>
>
> Description:
> Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
> Autobeaming now depends on context properties that can be
> \set by the user.   When the time signature is changed, default
> autobeam settings for the time signature are read and the context
> properties are changed to set the autobeaming properties.
>
> This change eliminates \overrideBeamSettings and 
> \revertBeamSettings.
>
> New functions have been defined to set time signature default
> properties:
> \overrideTimeSignatureSettings
> and
> \revertTimeSignatureSettings
> in order to give autobeam settings persistence through time 
> signature
> changes.
>
> A Scheme function make-setting has been defined to make it
> easier to create a time signature setting.
>
> Please review this at http://codereview.appspot.com/1667041/show
>
> Affected files:
>   M Documentation/de/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/es/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/fr/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/snippets/accordion-discant-symbols.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-a-figured-bass-above-or-below-the-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-ambitus-per-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-bar-lines-to-chordnames-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-drum-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-fingerings-to-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-the-current-date-to-a-score.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-volta-brackets-to-additional-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/additional-voices-to-avoid-collisions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adjusting-lyrics-vertical-spacing.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adjusting-the-shape-of-falls-and-doits.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/aligning-bar-numbers.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/aligning-marks-with-various-notation-objects.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/allowing-fingerings-to-be-printed-inside-the-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ambitus-with-multiple-voices.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-fonts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-gregorian-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-mensural-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/applying-note-head-styles-depending-on-the-step-of-the-scale.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/arabic-improvisation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beams-across-line-breaks.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing--flageolet-mark-size.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-beam-knee-gap.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-chord-separator.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-form-of-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-partcombine-texts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-text-and-spanner-styles-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-breath-mark-symbol.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-positions-of-figured-bass-alterations.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tempo-without-a-metronome-mark.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tuplet-number.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-exceptions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-major7.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chordchanges-for-fretboards.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chords-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/clip-systems.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/combining-two-parts-on-the-same-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/contemporary-glissando.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-spanner-visibility-after-a-line-break.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-placement-of-chord-fingerings.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-vertical-ordering-of-scripts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/creating-a-delayed-turn.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-arpeggios-across-notes-in-different-voices.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-a-piano-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-other-contexts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-metronome-marks-in-markup-mode.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-fretboard-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-markup-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/default-direction-of-stems-on-the-center-line-of-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/defining-predefined-fretboards-for-other-instruments.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/display-bracket-with-only-one-staff-in-a-system.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-complex-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-grob-ancestry.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/dodecaphonic-style-accidentals-for-each-note-including-naturals.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-custom-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/editorial-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/engraving-ties-manually.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/entering-several-tuplets-using-only-one--times-command.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/expressive-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/faking-a-hammer-in-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/figured-bass-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/fingerings,-string-indications,-and-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flamenco-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flat-flags-and-beam-nibs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/forcing-horizontal-shift-of-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/fretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/grid-lines--changing-their-appearance.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/grouping-beats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-slides.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-strum-rhythms.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/hiding-the-extender-line-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/incipit.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/indicating-cross-staff-chords-with-arpeggio-bracket.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/inserting-a-caesura.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/isolated-percent-repeats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/jazz-combo-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/keyboard-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/letter-tablature-formatting.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/makam-example.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-slurs-with-complex-dash-structure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-some-staff-lines-thicker-than-the-others.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/mensurstriche-layout-bar-lines-between-the-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/modern-tab-text-clef.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/modifying-default-values-for-articulation-shorthand-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/multi-measure-rest-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/nesting-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/new/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/new/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/fretted-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-default-tuplet-numbers.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-traditional-key-signatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/numbers-as-easy-note-heads.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/orchestra,-choir-and-piano-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ottava-text.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-count-visibility.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-counter.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/permitting-line-breaks-within-beamed-tuplets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-melody-and-lyrics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/pitches-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/placement-of-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/polyphony-in-tablature.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-grace-notes-with-floating-space.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/positioning-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-text-markups-inside-slurs.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-extra-naturals-from-being-automatically-added.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-natural-signs-from-being-printed-when-the-key-signature-changes.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-a-repeat-sign-at-the-beginning-of-a-piece.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-at-regular-intervals.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-inside-boxes-or-circles.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-hairpins-using-al-niente-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/printing-marks-on-every-staff.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/printing-metronome-and-rehearsal-marks-below-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-the-bar-number-for-the-first-measure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice-with-transposition.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/redefining-grace-note-global-defaults.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-bar-numbers-from-a-score.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-the-first-empty-line.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/repeats-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rest-styles.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rhythms-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/scheme-engraver-ambitus.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/screech-boink.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-hairpin-behavior-at-bar-lines.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-the-minimum-length-of-hairpins.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/shortening-volta-brackets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/showing-chords-at-changes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simple-lead-sheet.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simultaneous-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes,-lyrics,-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-only-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/snap-pizzicato-bartok-pizzicato.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/staff-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stand-alone-two-column-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stem-and-beam-behavior-in-tablature.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-with-separate-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/sub-dividing-beams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/text-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/transposing-pitches-with-minimum-accidentals-smart-transpose.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-clef-properties.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-grace-layout-within-music.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/unfretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/use-square-bracket-at-the-start-of-a-staff-group.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-double-slurs-for-legato-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-grace-note-slashes-with-normal-heads.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-ly-grob-object-to-access-grobs-with--tweak.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-the-whiteout-property.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-ties-with-arpeggios.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligned-dynamics-and-textscripts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligning-ossias-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-automatic-piano-reduction.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-lyrics-aligned-below-and-above-the-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-verse-and-refrain.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/volta-below-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/wind-headword.ly
>   M input/regression/les-nereides.ly
>   M lily/auto-beam-engraver.cc
>   M lily/beam-setting-scheme.cc
>   M lily/beaming-pattern.cc
>   M lily/include/beam-settings.hh
>   M lily/measure-grouping-engraver.cc
>   M ly/bagpipe.ly
>   M ly/engraver-init.ly
>   M ly/music-functions-init.ly
>   M python/convertrules.py
>   M scm/auto-beam.scm
>   M scm/define-context-properties.scm
>   M scm/lily-library.scm
>   M scm/lily.scm
>   M scm/music-functions.scm
>   A scm/time-signature-settings.scm
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-devel mailing list
> lilypond-devel@gnu.org
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
>
> 

[Neil Puttock, 2010-06-13 19:01:48]

Hi Carl,

Are you sure this is ready for review?

I see comments like this,

// I removed this to solve a bug; need to make sure it's right -- cds

and commented debug code,

+;(display "\nIn auto-beam.scm\n")

and alarm bells start to ring. :)

Also, there are several places where beamSettings is capitalized (most
importantly, in bagpipe.ly.)

BTW, what happens if a time signature has no default settings?

Cheers,
Neil

[t.daniels_treda.co.uk, 2010-06-14 18:18:21]

Hi Carl

I downloaded and applied Patch set 1, but make failed with

make[2]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower/include'
make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower'
make[1]: Entering directory `/media/Data/lily'
rm -f ./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep; 
DEPENDENCIES_OUTPUT="./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep 
./out/auto-beam-engraver.o" 
++ -c -Woverloaded-virtual  -I/usr/include/python2.6 -I/usr/include/python2.6 
 -fno-strict-aliasing  -g -fwrapv     -DHAVE_CONFIG_H  -DNDEBUG -I./include 
 -I./out -I../flower/include -I../flower/./out -I../flower/include   
-O2 -finline-functions -g -pipe -pthread -I/usr/include/freetype2    
-I/usr/include/pango-1.0 -I/usr/include/freetype2 -I/usr/include/glib-2.0 
 -I/usr/lib/glib-2.0/include   -Wno-pmf-conversions  -W -Wall -Wconversion 
 -o out/auto-beam-engraver.o auto-beam-engraver.cc
make[1]: *** No rule to make target `include/beam-settings.hh', 
needed by `out/beaming-pattern.o'.  Stop.
make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/lily'
make: *** [all] Error 2

Trevor

----- Original Message ----- 
From: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
To: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
Cc: <reply@codereview.appspotmail.com>; <lilypond-devel@gnu.org>
Sent: Sunday, June 13, 2010 2:47 AM
Subject: Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier 
(issue1667041)


> Reviewers: ,
>
> Message:
> I have *finally* completed the autobeaming patch.
>
> The patch eliminates beamSettings as a major alist containing 
> settings
> for various time signatures.
>
> Instead, autobeaming is controlled by some simple context 
> properties:
>
> beamSettings, beatLength, and measureGrouping.
>
> In order to give a persistent setting for autobeaming, there is 
> also a
> context property timeSignatureSettings that stores default values 
> of
> measureGrouping, beatLength, and beamSettings for a given time
> signature.
>
> The defaults can be overridden and reverted with
> overrideTimeSignatureSettings and revertTimeSignatureSettings.
>
> To facilitate doing the override, there is a scheme function
> make-setting that constructs the appropriate timeSignatureSetting 
> from a
> given beatLength, measureGrouping, and beamSettings.
>
> This patch contains lots of snippets because I needed to run 
> makelsr in
> order to get the snippets out of Documentation/snippets/new/ in 
> order to
> test the documentation build.
>
> Thanks,
>
> Carl
>
>
> Description:
> Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
> Autobeaming now depends on context properties that can be
> \set by the user.   When the time signature is changed, default
> autobeam settings for the time signature are read and the context
> properties are changed to set the autobeaming properties.
>
> This change eliminates \overrideBeamSettings and 
> \revertBeamSettings.
>
> New functions have been defined to set time signature default
> properties:
> \overrideTimeSignatureSettings
> and
> \revertTimeSignatureSettings
> in order to give autobeam settings persistence through time 
> signature
> changes.
>
> A Scheme function make-setting has been defined to make it
> easier to create a time signature setting.
>
> Please review this at http://codereview.appspot.com/1667041/show
>
> Affected files:
>   M Documentation/de/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/es/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/fr/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/notation/rhythms.itely
>   M Documentation/snippets/accordion-discant-symbols.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-a-figured-bass-above-or-below-the-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-ambitus-per-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-bar-lines-to-chordnames-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-drum-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-fingerings-to-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-the-current-date-to-a-score.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adding-volta-brackets-to-additional-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/additional-voices-to-avoid-collisions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/adjusting-lyrics-vertical-spacing.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/adjusting-the-shape-of-falls-and-doits.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/aligning-bar-numbers.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/aligning-marks-with-various-notation-objects.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/allowing-fingerings-to-be-printed-inside-the-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ambitus-with-multiple-voices.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-fonts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-gregorian-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-mensural-music.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/applying-note-head-styles-depending-on-the-step-of-the-scale.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/arabic-improvisation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/beams-across-line-breaks.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing--flageolet-mark-size.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-beam-knee-gap.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-chord-separator.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-form-of-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-partcombine-texts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-text-and-spanner-styles-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-breath-mark-symbol.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-positions-of-figured-bass-alterations.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tempo-without-a-metronome-mark.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tuplet-number.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-exceptions.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-major7.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chordchanges-for-fretboards.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/chords-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/clip-systems.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/combining-two-parts-on-the-same-staff.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/contemporary-glissando.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-spanner-visibility-after-a-line-break.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-placement-of-chord-fingerings.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-vertical-ordering-of-scripts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/creating-a-delayed-turn.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-arpeggios-across-notes-in-different-voices.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-a-piano-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-other-contexts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/creating-metronome-marks-in-markup-mode.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-fretboard-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-markup-fret-diagrams.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/default-direction-of-stems-on-the-center-line-of-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/defining-predefined-fretboards-for-other-instruments.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/display-bracket-with-only-one-staff-in-a-system.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-complex-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-grob-ancestry.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/dodecaphonic-style-accidentals-for-each-note-including-naturals.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-custom-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/editorial-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/engraving-ties-manually.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/entering-several-tuplets-using-only-one--times-command.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/expressive-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/faking-a-hammer-in-tablatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/figured-bass-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/fingerings,-string-indications,-and-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flamenco-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/flat-flags-and-beam-nibs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/forcing-horizontal-shift-of-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/fretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/grid-lines--changing-their-appearance.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/grouping-beats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-slides.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-strum-rhythms.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/hiding-the-extender-line-for-text-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/incipit.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/indicating-cross-staff-chords-with-arpeggio-bracket.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/inserting-a-caesura.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/isolated-percent-repeats.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/jazz-combo-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/keyboard-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/letter-tablature-formatting.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/makam-example.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-slurs-with-complex-dash-structure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/making-some-staff-lines-thicker-than-the-others.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/mensurstriche-layout-bar-lines-between-the-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/modern-tab-text-clef.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/modifying-default-values-for-articulation-shorthand-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/multi-measure-rest-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/nesting-staves.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/new/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beaming.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/compound-time-signatures.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/new/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/fretted-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/new/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-default-tuplet-numbers.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/non-traditional-key-signatures.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/numbers-as-easy-note-heads.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/orchestra,-choir-and-piano-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/ottava-text.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-count-visibility.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-counter.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/permitting-line-breaks-within-beamed-tuplets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-dynamics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-melody-and-lyrics.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/pitches-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/placement-of-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/polyphony-in-tablature.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-grace-notes-with-floating-space.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/positioning-multi-measure-rests.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/positioning-text-markups-inside-slurs.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-extra-naturals-from-being-automatically-added.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/preventing-natural-signs-from-being-printed-when-the-key-signature-changes.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-a-repeat-sign-at-the-beginning-of-a-piece.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-at-regular-intervals.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-inside-boxes-or-circles.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-hairpins-using-al-niente-notation.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/printing-marks-on-every-staff.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/printing-metronome-and-rehearsal-marks-below-the-staff.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/printing-the-bar-number-for-the-first-measure.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice-with-transposition.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/redefining-grace-note-global-defaults.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-bar-numbers-from-a-score.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-the-first-empty-line.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/repeats-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rest-styles.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/rhythms-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/scheme-engraver-ambitus.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/screech-boink.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-hairpin-behavior-at-bar-lines.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/setting-the-minimum-length-of-hairpins.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/shortening-volta-brackets.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/showing-chords-at-changes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simple-lead-sheet.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/simultaneous-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes,-lyrics,-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-only-notes.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/snap-pizzicato-bartok-pizzicato.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/staff-headword.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stand-alone-two-column-markup.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/stem-and-beam-behavior-in-tablature.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-simple.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-with-separate-parts.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/sub-dividing-beams.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/text-headword.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/transposing-pitches-with-minimum-accidentals-smart-transpose.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-clef-properties.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-grace-layout-within-music.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/unfretted-headword.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/use-square-bracket-at-the-start-of-a-staff-group.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-double-slurs-for-legato-chords.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-grace-note-slashes-with-normal-heads.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/using-ly-grob-object-to-access-grobs-with--tweak.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-the-whiteout-property.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/using-ties-with-arpeggios.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligned-dynamics-and-textscripts.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligning-ossias-and-lyrics.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-automatic-piano-reduction.ly
>   M 
>
Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-lyrics-aligned-below-and-above-the-staves.ly
>   M 
> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-verse-and-refrain.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/volta-below-chords.ly
>   M Documentation/snippets/wind-headword.ly
>   M input/regression/les-nereides.ly
>   M lily/auto-beam-engraver.cc
>   M lily/beam-setting-scheme.cc
>   M lily/beaming-pattern.cc
>   M lily/include/beam-settings.hh
>   M lily/measure-grouping-engraver.cc
>   M ly/bagpipe.ly
>   M ly/engraver-init.ly
>   M ly/music-functions-init.ly
>   M python/convertrules.py
>   M scm/auto-beam.scm
>   M scm/define-context-properties.scm
>   M scm/lily-library.scm
>   M scm/lily.scm
>   M scm/music-functions.scm
>   A scm/time-signature-settings.scm
>
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> lilypond-devel mailing list
> lilypond-devel@gnu.org
> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
>
> 

[c_sorensen, 2010-06-14 18:25:59]

You need to do make clean first, because we've removed some source files.

I should have mentioned that in the review request.

Thanks,

Carl



On 6/14/10 12:18 PM, "Trevor Daniels" <t.daniels@treda.co.uk> wrote:

> Hi Carl
>
> I downloaded and applied Patch set 1, but make failed with
>
> make[2]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower/include'
> make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower'
> make[1]: Entering directory `/media/Data/lily'
> rm -f ./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep;
> DEPENDENCIES_OUTPUT="./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep
> ./out/auto-beam-engraver.o"
> ++ -c -Woverloaded-virtual  -I/usr/include/python2.6 -I/usr/include/python2.6
>  -fno-strict-aliasing  -g -fwrapv     -DHAVE_CONFIG_H  -DNDEBUG -I./include
>  -I./out -I../flower/include -I../flower/./out -I../flower/include
> -O2 -finline-functions -g -pipe -pthread -I/usr/include/freetype2
> -I/usr/include/pango-1.0 -I/usr/include/freetype2 -I/usr/include/glib-2.0
>  -I/usr/lib/glib-2.0/include   -Wno-pmf-conversions  -W -Wall -Wconversion
>  -o out/auto-beam-engraver.o auto-beam-engraver.cc
> make[1]: *** No rule to make target `include/beam-settings.hh',
> needed by `out/beaming-pattern.o'.  Stop.
> make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/lily'
> make: *** [all] Error 2
>
> Trevor
>
> ----- Original Message -----
> From: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
> To: <Carl.D.Sorensen@gmail.com>
> Cc: <reply@codereview.appspotmail.com>; <lilypond-devel@gnu.org>
> Sent: Sunday, June 13, 2010 2:47 AM
> Subject: Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
> (issue1667041)
>
>
>> Reviewers: ,
>>
>> Message:
>> I have *finally* completed the autobeaming patch.
>>
>> The patch eliminates beamSettings as a major alist containing
>> settings
>> for various time signatures.
>>
>> Instead, autobeaming is controlled by some simple context
>> properties:
>>
>> beamSettings, beatLength, and measureGrouping.
>>
>> In order to give a persistent setting for autobeaming, there is
>> also a
>> context property timeSignatureSettings that stores default values
>> of
>> measureGrouping, beatLength, and beamSettings for a given time
>> signature.
>>
>> The defaults can be overridden and reverted with
>> overrideTimeSignatureSettings and revertTimeSignatureSettings.
>>
>> To facilitate doing the override, there is a scheme function
>> make-setting that constructs the appropriate timeSignatureSetting
>> from a
>> given beatLength, measureGrouping, and beamSettings.
>>
>> This patch contains lots of snippets because I needed to run
>> makelsr in
>> order to get the snippets out of Documentation/snippets/new/ in
>> order to
>> test the documentation build.
>>
>> Thanks,
>>
>> Carl
>>
>>
>> Description:
>> Redo autobeam settings to make resetting easier
>> Autobeaming now depends on context properties that can be
>> \set by the user.   When the time signature is changed, default
>> autobeam settings for the time signature are read and the context
>> properties are changed to set the autobeaming properties.
>>
>> This change eliminates \overrideBeamSettings and
>> \revertBeamSettings.
>>
>> New functions have been defined to set time signature default
>> properties:
>> \overrideTimeSignatureSettings
>> and
>> \revertTimeSignatureSettings
>> in order to give autobeam settings persistence through time
>> signature
>> changes.
>>
>> A Scheme function make-setting has been defined to make it
>> easier to create a time signature setting.
>>
>> Please review this at http://codereview.appspot.com/1667041/show
>>
>> Affected files:
>>   M Documentation/de/notation/rhythms.itely
>>   M Documentation/es/notation/rhythms.itely
>>   M Documentation/fr/notation/rhythms.itely
>>   M Documentation/notation/rhythms.itely
>>   M Documentation/snippets/accordion-discant-symbols.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/adding-a-figured-bass-above-or-below-the-notes.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-ambitus-per-voice.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/adding-bar-lines-to-chordnames-context.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-drum-parts.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-fingerings-to-tablatures.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/adding-the-current-date-to-a-score.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/adding-volta-brackets-to-additional-staves.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/additional-voices-to-avoid-collisions.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/adjusting-lyrics-vertical-spacing.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/adjusting-the-shape-of-falls-and-doits.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/aligning-bar-numbers.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/aligning-marks-with-various-notation-objects.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/allowing-fingerings-to-be-printed-inside-the-staff.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/ambitus-with-multiple-voices.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-fonts.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/ancient-headword.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-g
>> regorian-music.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/ancient-notation-template----modern-transcription-of-m
>> ensural-music.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/applying-note-head-styles-depending-on-the-step-of-the
>> -scale.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/arabic-improvisation.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/beams-across-line-breaks.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing--flageolet-mark-size.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-beam-knee-gap.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-chord-separator.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-form-of-multi-measure-rests.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-partcombine-texts.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/changing-text-and-spanner-styles-for-text-dynamics.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-breath-mark-symbol.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-positions-of-figured-bass-alterations.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tempo-without-a-metronome-mark.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-beam
>> ing.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/changing-the-tuplet-number.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-exceptions.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/chord-name-major7.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/chordchanges-for-fretboards.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/chords-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/clip-systems.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/combining-two-parts-on-the-same-staff.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/compound-time-signatures.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/contemporary-glissando.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/controlling-spanner-visibility-after-a-line-break.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-placement-of-chord-fingerings.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/controlling-the-vertical-ordering-of-scripts.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/creating-a-delayed-turn.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/creating-arpeggios-across-notes-in-different-voices.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-a-piano-staff.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/creating-cross-staff-arpeggios-in-other-contexts.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/creating-metronome-marks-in-markup-mode.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-fretboard-fret-diagrams.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/customizing-markup-fret-diagrams.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/default-direction-of-stems-on-the-center-line-of-the-s
>> taff.ly
>>   M
>>
Documentation/snippets/defining-predefined-fretboards-for-other-instruments.l>>
y
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/display-bracket-with-only-one-staff-in-a-system.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-complex-chords.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/displaying-grob-ancestry.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/dodecaphonic-style-accidentals-for-each-note-including
>> -naturals.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-custom-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/dynamics-text-spanner-postfix.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/editorial-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/engraving-ties-manually.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/entering-several-tuplets-using-only-one--times-command
>> .ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/expressive-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/faking-a-hammer-in-tablatures.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/figured-bass-headword.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/fingerings,-string-indications,-and-right-hand-fingeri
>> ngs.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/flamenco-notation.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/flat-flags-and-beam-nibs.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/forcing-horizontal-shift-of-notes.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/fretted-headword.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/grid-lines--changing-their-appearance.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/grouping-beats.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-slides.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/guitar-strum-rhythms.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/hiding-the-extender-line-for-text-dynamics.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/incipit.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/indicating-cross-staff-chords-with-arpeggio-bracket.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/inserting-a-caesura.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/isolated-percent-repeats.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/jazz-combo-template.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/keyboard-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/letter-tablature-formatting.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/makam-example.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/making-slurs-with-complex-dash-structure.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/making-some-staff-lines-thicker-than-the-others.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/mensurstriche-layout-bar-lines-between-the-staves.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/modern-tab-text-clef.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/modifying-default-values-for-articulation-shorthand-no
>> tation.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/multi-measure-rest-markup.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/nesting-staves.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-endings-in-score-context.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/new/beam-grouping-in-7-8-time.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/new/changing-the-time-signature-without-affecting-the-
>> beaming.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/new/compound-time-signatures.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/new/conducting-signs,-measure-grouping-signs.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/new/fretted-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/new/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/non-default-tuplet-numbers.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/non-traditional-key-signatures.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/numbers-as-easy-note-heads.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/orchestra,-choir-and-piano-template.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/ottava-text.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-count-visibility.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/percent-repeat-counter.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/permitting-line-breaks-within-beamed-tuplets.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-simple.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-dynamics.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-centered-lyrics.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/piano-template-with-melody-and-lyrics.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/pitches-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/placement-of-right-hand-fingerings.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/polyphony-in-tablature.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/positioning-grace-notes-with-floating-space.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/positioning-multi-measure-rests.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/positioning-text-markups-inside-slurs.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/preventing-extra-naturals-from-being-automatically-add
>> ed.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/preventing-natural-signs-from-being-printed-when-the-k
>> ey-signature-changes.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-a-repeat-sign-at-the-beginning-of-a-piece.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-at-regular-intervals.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-bar-numbers-inside-boxes-or-circles.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-hairpins-using-al-niente-notation.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/printing-marks-on-every-staff.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-metronome-and-rehearsal-marks-below-the-staff
>> .ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/printing-the-bar-number-for-the-first-measure.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice-with-transposition.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/quoting-another-voice.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/redefining-grace-note-global-defaults.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-bar-numbers-from-a-score.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/removing-the-first-empty-line.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/repeats-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/rest-styles.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/reverting-default-beam-endings.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/rhythms-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/scheme-engraver-ambitus.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/screech-boink.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/setting-hairpin-behavior-at-bar-lines.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/setting-the-minimum-length-of-hairpins.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/shortening-volta-brackets.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/showing-chords-at-changes.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/simple-lead-sheet.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/simultaneous-headword.ly
>>   M
>>
Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes,-lyrics,-and-chords.l>>
y
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-chords.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-notes-and-lyrics.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/single-staff-template-with-only-notes.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/snap-pizzicato-bartok-pizzicato.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/staff-headword.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/stand-alone-two-column-markup.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/stem-and-beam-behavior-in-tablature.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-simple.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/string-quartet-template-with-separate-parts.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/sub-dividing-beams.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/text-headword.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/transposing-pitches-with-minimum-accidentals-smart-tra
>> nspose.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-clef-properties.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/tweaking-grace-layout-within-music.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/unfretted-headword.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/use-square-bracket-at-the-start-of-a-staff-group.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/using-double-slurs-for-legato-chords.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/using-grace-note-slashes-with-normal-heads.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/using-ly-grob-object-to-access-grobs-with--tweak.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/using-the-whiteout-property.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/using-ties-with-arpeggios.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligned-dynamics-and-textscripts.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/vertically-aligning-ossias-and-lyrics.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-automatic-piano-reduction
>> .ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-lyrics-aligned-below-and-
>> above-the-staves.ly
>>   M
>> Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template-with-verse-and-refrain.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/vocal-ensemble-template.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/volta-below-chords.ly
>>   M Documentation/snippets/wind-headword.ly
>>   M input/regression/les-nereides.ly
>>   M lily/auto-beam-engraver.cc
>>   M lily/beam-setting-scheme.cc
>>   M lily/beaming-pattern.cc
>>   M lily/include/beam-settings.hh
>>   M lily/measure-grouping-engraver.cc
>>   M ly/bagpipe.ly
>>   M ly/engraver-init.ly
>>   M ly/music-functions-init.ly
>>   M python/convertrules.py
>>   M scm/auto-beam.scm
>>   M scm/define-context-properties.scm
>>   M scm/lily-library.scm
>>   M scm/lily.scm
>>   M scm/music-functions.scm
>>   A scm/time-signature-settings.scm
>>
>>
>>
>> _______________________________________________
>> lilypond-devel mailing list
>> lilypond-devel@gnu.org
>> http://lists.gnu.org/mailman/listinfo/lilypond-devel
>>
>>
>
>

[Neil Puttock, 2010-06-14 18:28:15]

Hi Trevor,

On 2010/06/14 18:18:21, t.daniels_treda.co.uk wrote:

> I downloaded and applied Patch set 1, but make failed with
> 
> make[2]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower/include'
> make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/flower'
> make[1]: Entering directory `/media/Data/lily'
> rm -f ./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep; 
> DEPENDENCIES_OUTPUT="./out/auto-beam-engraver.dep 
> ./out/auto-beam-engraver.o" 
> ++ -c -Woverloaded-virtual  -I/usr/include/python2.6 -I/usr/include/python2.6 
>  -fno-strict-aliasing  -g -fwrapv     -DHAVE_CONFIG_H  -DNDEBUG -I./include 
>  -I./out -I../flower/include -I../flower/./out -I../flower/include   
> -O2 -finline-functions -g -pipe -pthread -I/usr/include/freetype2    
> -I/usr/include/pango-1.0 -I/usr/include/freetype2 -I/usr/include/glib-2.0 
>  -I/usr/lib/glib-2.0/include   -Wno-pmf-conversions  -W -Wall -Wconversion 
>  -o out/auto-beam-engraver.o auto-beam-engraver.cc
> make[1]: *** No rule to make target `include/beam-settings.hh', 
> needed by `out/beaming-pattern.o'.  Stop.
> make[1]: Leaving directory `/media/Data/lily'
> make: *** [all] Error 2

I had to run `make bin-clean' and recompile to get round this.

Cheers,
Neil

[Graham Percival, 2010-06-14 19:00:38]

On Mon, Jun 14, 2010 at 06:28:15PM +0000, n.puttock@gmail.com wrote:
> I had to run `make bin-clean' and recompile to get round this.

Please tell me that "bin-clean" doesn't do anything that:
	make doc-clean
	make clean
	make distclean
doesn't do.

(ok, time to edit the CG again...)

Cheers,
- Graham

[c_sorensen, 2010-06-14 19:05:06]

On 6/14/10 1:00 PM, "Graham Percival" <graham@percival-music.ca> wrote:

> On Mon, Jun 14, 2010 at 06:28:15PM +0000, n.puttock@gmail.com wrote:
>> I had to run `make bin-clean' and recompile to get round this.
> 
> Please tell me that "bin-clean" doesn't do anything that:
>         make doc-clean
>         make clean
>         make distclean
> doesn't do.

bin-clean should just clean up the binaries.

make distclean is everything, as I understand it.

make clean is everything but configuration files.

make bin-clean is binary files (i.e. it leaves the docs alone and the fonts
alone, I think).

make doc-clean is documentation + fonts, I think.

So I think that make clean is essentially the same as make bin-clean and
make doc-clean.

But I haven't checked this out with the sources, because I can't follow
them....
> 
> (ok, time to edit the CG again...)

Hence the chapter on the build system that I proposed...
> 


Thanks,

Carl

[Neil Puttock, 2010-06-14 19:10:47]

On 14 June 2010 20:04, Carl Sorensen <c_sorensen@byu.edu> wrote:

> bin-clean should just clean up the binaries.

Yup, it saves having to rebuild fonts, so in this case shaves off a
significant proportion of the total build time.

> make doc-clean is documentation + fonts, I think.

Docs only.

Cheers,
Neil

[Graham Percival, 2010-06-14 19:21:04]

On Mon, Jun 14, 2010 at 01:04:46PM -0600, Carl Sorensen wrote:
> make distclean is everything, as I understand it.

Doesn't do doc stuff.  Might not do other stuff, as well.

> > (ok, time to edit the CG again...)
> 
> Hence the chapter on the build system that I proposed...

If anything needs to be said about bin-clean (and it looks like it
doesn't), then we could just shove it in CG 3 for now.

Cheers,
- Graham

[t.daniels_treda.co.uk, 2010-06-14 22:00:59]

Neil Puttock wrote 14 June 2010
> On 14 June 2010 20:04, Carl Sorensen <c_sorensen@byu.edu> wrote:
>
>> bin-clean should just clean up the binaries.
>
> Yup, it saves having to rebuild fonts, so in this case shaves off 
> a
> significant proportion of the total build time.

I saw this just after doing make clean, make.
Sure enough, make was rebuilding the fonts :(

Looks like it will be tomorrow before I get to the whirling.

Trevor

[c_sorensen, 2010-06-14 23:01:39]

On 6/14/10 4:00 PM, "Trevor Daniels" <t.daniels@treda.co.uk> wrote:

> 
> 
> Neil Puttock wrote 14 June 2010
>> On 14 June 2010 20:04, Carl Sorensen <c_sorensen@byu.edu> wrote:
>> 
>>> bin-clean should just clean up the binaries.
>> 
>> Yup, it saves having to rebuild fonts, so in this case shaves off
>> a
>> significant proportion of the total build time.
> 
> I saw this just after doing make clean, make.
> Sure enough, make was rebuilding the fonts :(

I'm sorry.  I didn't know about bin-clean.

> 
> Looks like it will be tomorrow before I get to the whirling.
> 

Just imagine trying to do font development work (which I've done in the past
few weeks)....

Carl

[t.daniels_treda.co.uk, 2010-06-14 23:20:35]

Carl Sorensen wrote Tuesday, June 15, 2010 12:01 AM

> On 6/14/10 4:00 PM, "Trevor Daniels" <t.daniels@treda.co.uk> 
> wrote:
>
>> Neil Puttock wrote 14 June 2010
>>> On 14 June 2010 20:04, Carl Sorensen <c_sorensen@byu.edu> wrote:
>>>
>>>> bin-clean should just clean up the binaries.
>>>
>>> Yup, it saves having to rebuild fonts, so in this case shaves 
>>> off
>>> a
>>> significant proportion of the total build time.
>>
>> I saw this just after doing make clean, make.
>> Sure enough, make was rebuilding the fonts :(
>
> I'm sorry.  I didn't know about bin-clean.

No problem.  Actually it's finished already - looks like
make clean leaves the docs and web intact ??  But it's
already tomorrow here, so I'll have to leave it for now.

> Just imagine trying to do font development work (which I've done 
> in the past
> few weeks)....

I learnt long ago that _anything_ to do with LilyPond
is 5 times more complex that you think, and takes at
least 10 times longer than you might expect.  Maybe
that makes it 10 times the fun ;)

> Carl
Trevor